RT @JoshBBornstein: 65 year study confirms my research: Tax cuts don't lead to economic growth. Ping @Nick_Xenophon , @BCAcomau https://t.…
19/08/2017 9:13 PM
RT @attn: .@Schwarzenegger has a blunt message for Nazis. https://t.co/HAbnejahtl
18/08/2017 9:38 PM
RT @PositiveMoneyUK: Make Monetary Policy Fair: It's time to explore alternatives to 'conventional' QE. https://t.co/m6CFVojm7w #QEforPeopl…
18/08/2017 9:35 PM
@deirdrekent To be expected when income is taxed and capital gain not...
16/08/2017 9:22 PM
@bernardchickey @YourHomeLoanNZ Add ring fencing loses / deal to negative gearing and we might see some balance develop in the economy.
16/08/2017 7:36 PM
@bernardchickey Or take the job and do the right thing anyway - the RBNZ is "independent" after all...
16/08/2017 7:34 PM
@bernardchickey Not take the job because you would know you would be on a hiding to nothing. The link between earn… https://t.co/nxPRuAaT6t
16/08/2017 7:31 PM
RT @theyearofelan: Sure, the cancer was aggressive. But the chemotherapy was also very aggressive. There was aggression on both sides
16/08/2017 7:27 PM
@bernardchickey DTI+LVR+OCR all needed for financial stability & inflation.RBNZ can then push back on dumb policy f… https://t.co/CqXISZUHGq
16/08/2017 7:27 PM
@SelwynPellett Farming capital gains makes it hard to pay current expenses hence the need to externalise costs. Th… https://t.co/J1yevZAHft
14/08/2017 5:46 PM
Recent Post Comments
I am sorry but this comment section has been disabled due to spam. My contact details are easy to find, please contact me if you want to comment or discuss anything on this blog.

Print-friendly
19
NOV 12

Comment on John Kay's Article




John Kay recently wrote an article entitled “Fetish for making things ignores real work”.

The point John makes in this piece is, what he calls “manufacturing fetishism – the idea that manufacturing is the central economic activity and everything else is somehow subordinate” is fundamentally wrong. He believes that the design and service behind manufacturing is what truly creates value and that is what deserves recognition. The example used is the Apple iPhone, as the raw material and labour costs involved in manufacturing it are very small, but its design, research involved and “made in China, designed in California”, is what causes it to be a valuable item.

In my view John is confusing manufacturing with production. Manufacturing incorporates all parts of the process in creating a product, from idea conception - driven by market needs, design, research, developments, supply, production, distribution, service provision, sales and marketing – through to its consumption. He is focused on the production element in the all-embracing manufacturing process – semantics maybe but critical to communication on the issues. Equally few in the manufacturing world confuse products and devices, a product is the combination of a device and associated services – maybe semantics again but these are important distinctions.

As the prime mover in the economy there should be a fetish for manufacturing and its growth supported in order to grow the real economy and raise our living standards – as Angus Tait said, there are three ways to make real wealth – grow things, dig things up and make things, on the latter he was not referring to the act of production but the process of manufacturing.
 


tags: john kay, manufacturing, production
I am sorry but this comment section has been disabled due to spam. My contact details are easy to find, please contact me if you want to comment or discuss anything on this blog.